A Comparative Study of Graph Matching Algorithms in Computer Vision

Benchmark Results for “worms18”

This page shows the benchmarks results for the dataset instance “worms18”. We consider solutions as optimal if the objective value is within a 0.1% range of the known optimum -48236.3.

Run time 1s

method value bound optimal accuracy
dd-ls0 69687.3 -169468 no 23.85%
dd-ls3 67699.6 -166155 no 22.70%
dd-ls4 64804 -165810 no 26.15%
fgmd inf -inf no –
fm-bca -48236.3 -48247 yes 86.78%
fm -48236.3 -55661.6 yes 86.78%
fw -47378.5 -inf no 82.76%
ga inf -inf no –
hbp inf -inf no –
ipfps inf -inf no –
ipfpu inf -inf no –
lsm inf -inf no –
mp inf -inf no –
mp-fw inf -inf no –
mpm inf -inf no –
mp-mcf inf -inf no –
pm inf -inf no –
rrwm inf -inf no –
sm inf -inf no –
smac inf -inf no –

Run time 10s

method value bound optimal accuracy
dd-ls0 54282 -151818 no 23.28%
dd-ls3 46099.5 -147873 no 25.00%
dd-ls4 59453.1 -154173 no 24.71%
fgmd inf -inf no –
fm-bca -48236.3 -48242.3 yes 86.78%
fm -48236.3 -55661.6 yes 86.78%
fw -48039.8 -inf no 85.34%
ga inf -inf no –
hbp inf -inf no –
ipfps inf -inf no –
ipfpu 0 -inf no 0.00%
lsm inf -inf no –
mp -48224.1 -48243.4 yes 86.78%
mp-fw inf -49618.8 no 0.00%
mpm inf -inf no –
mp-mcf -47907.3 -48313.5 no 85.63%
pm inf -inf no –
rrwm inf -inf no –
sm inf -inf no –
smac inf -inf no –

Run time 100s

method value bound optimal accuracy
dd-ls0 -6068.7 -56668.8 no 57.18%
dd-ls3 11310.4 -70377.1 no 43.39%
dd-ls4 34210.3 -107533 no 32.47%
fgmd inf -inf no –
fm-bca -48236.3 -48242.3 yes 86.78%
fm -48236.3 -55661.6 yes 86.78%
fw -48039.8 -inf no 85.34%
ga inf -inf no –
hbp inf -inf no –
ipfps -1077.39 -inf no 1.44%
ipfpu 0 -inf no 0.00%
lsm inf -inf no –
mp -48224.1 -48242.3 yes 86.78%
mp-fw -48214.8 -48342.1 yes 87.93%
mpm inf -inf no –
mp-mcf -47907.3 -48296.8 no 85.63%
pm inf -inf no –
rrwm inf -inf no –
sm -8049.88 -inf no 9.20%
smac inf -inf no –

Run time 300s

method value bound optimal accuracy
dd-ls0 -45890.4 -48344.4 no 85.06%
dd-ls3 -42875 -48568.4 no 85.06%
dd-ls4 13224.9 -74488.5 no 41.95%
fgmd inf -inf no –
fm-bca -48236.3 -48242.3 yes 86.78%
fm -48236.3 -55661.6 yes 86.78%
fw -48039.8 -inf no 85.34%
ga inf -inf no –
hbp inf -inf no –
ipfps -1077.39 -inf no 1.44%
ipfpu 0 -inf no 0.00%
lsm inf -inf no –
mp -48224.1 -48242.3 yes 86.78%
mp-fw -48217.1 -48332.1 yes 87.64%
mpm inf -inf no –
mp-mcf -47907.3 -48295.6 no 85.63%
pm inf -inf no –
rrwm inf -inf no –
sm -8049.88 -inf no 9.20%
smac inf -inf no –

Other Results for this Dataset

Accumulated results for whole dataset: worms

Results for individual instances of the dataset: