This page shows the benchmarks results for the dataset instance “car17”. We consider solutions as optimal if the objective value is within a 0.1% range of the known optimum -57.09.
Run time 1s
| method | value | bound | optimal | accuracy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dd-ls0 | -57.0892 | -57.0987 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls3 | -47.9749 | -60.1226 | no | 70.37% |
| dd-ls4 | -36.0391 | -63.9496 | no | 51.85% |
| fgmd | inf | -inf | no | – |
| fm-bca | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| fm | -57.0892 | -83.0876 | yes | 92.59% |
| fw | -52.307 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| ga | -52.2979 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| hbp | -57.0892 | -58.8315 | yes | 92.59% |
| ipfps | -54.6507 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| ipfpu | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| lsm | -48.1228 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mp-fw | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mpm | -51.1951 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp-mcf | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| pm | -35.3629 | -inf | no | 37.04% |
| rrwm | -56.7714 | -inf | no | 88.89% |
| sm | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| smac | -30.6798 | -inf | no | 33.33% |
Run time 10s
| method | value | bound | optimal | accuracy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dd-ls0 | -57.0892 | -57.0987 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls3 | -57.0892 | -57.0934 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls4 | -55.5474 | -57.5729 | no | 85.19% |
| fgmd | -57.0892 | -inf | yes | 92.59% |
| fm-bca | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| fm | -57.0892 | -83.0876 | yes | 92.59% |
| fw | -52.307 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| ga | -52.2979 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| hbp | -57.0892 | -58.8315 | yes | 92.59% |
| ipfps | -54.6507 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| ipfpu | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| lsm | -48.1228 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mp-fw | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mpm | -51.1951 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp-mcf | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| pm | -35.3629 | -inf | no | 37.04% |
| rrwm | -56.7714 | -inf | no | 88.89% |
| sm | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| smac | -30.6798 | -inf | no | 33.33% |
Run time 100s
| method | value | bound | optimal | accuracy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dd-ls0 | -57.0892 | -57.0987 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls3 | -57.0892 | -57.0934 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls4 | -57.0892 | -57.0919 | yes | 92.59% |
| fgmd | -57.0892 | -inf | yes | 92.59% |
| fm-bca | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| fm | -57.0892 | -83.0876 | yes | 92.59% |
| fw | -52.307 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| ga | -52.2979 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| hbp | -57.0892 | -58.8315 | yes | 92.59% |
| ipfps | -54.6507 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| ipfpu | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| lsm | -48.1228 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mp-fw | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mpm | -51.1951 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp-mcf | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| pm | -35.3629 | -inf | no | 37.04% |
| rrwm | -56.7714 | -inf | no | 88.89% |
| sm | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| smac | -30.6798 | -inf | no | 33.33% |
Run time 300s
| method | value | bound | optimal | accuracy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dd-ls0 | -57.0892 | -57.0987 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls3 | -57.0892 | -57.0934 | yes | 92.59% |
| dd-ls4 | -57.0892 | -57.0919 | yes | 92.59% |
| fgmd | -57.0892 | -inf | yes | 92.59% |
| fm-bca | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| fm | -57.0892 | -83.0876 | yes | 92.59% |
| fw | -52.307 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| ga | -52.2979 | -inf | no | 62.96% |
| hbp | -57.0892 | -58.8315 | yes | 92.59% |
| ipfps | -54.6507 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| ipfpu | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| lsm | -48.1228 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mp-fw | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| mpm | -51.1951 | -inf | no | 51.85% |
| mp-mcf | -57.0892 | -57.0892 | yes | 92.59% |
| pm | -35.3629 | -inf | no | 37.04% |
| rrwm | -56.7714 | -inf | no | 88.89% |
| sm | -53.0809 | -inf | no | 77.78% |
| smac | -30.6798 | -inf | no | 33.33% |
Other Results for this Dataset
Accumulated results for whole dataset: car
Results for individual instances of the dataset: